A letter from a Write or Remain Silent reader

The following is an email I received from a friend/acquaintance — one of a number of people I've come to know to varying degrees through both online and real-world election-related groups over the past year. Although I wouldn't normally devote a whole post to someone else's email, I wanted to include it on our class blog in part because the man who wrote it, Dan Greco, has been reading our blog for the past month or so. I don't usually hear back from readers, but it's nice to give them space here to share their views with our community as well. I actually got it right before Election Day, but haven't had time to get it onto the blog until now.

On the cusp of a new American moment……


I have had two full-time jobs the fast few months. In addition to my job as a tutor (the one that pays the bills), I have also been a full-time election addict, splitting my time in the blogosphere trying to decide if the minute gaffe Joe Biden made on Tuesday (really, on any day) has cost Obama’s chance at victory to slip from 96.4% to 94.9% on 538.com. Nate Silver has become our national electoral therapist. I wake up to the polls every morning, and routinely check liberal blogs several times per day. For my part, I have also canvassed New Hampshire five times and have called more than 2000 people in support of Pre…I mean Senator Obama.

I have finally let it sink in that, barring unforeseeable circumstances, Barack Obama will become the 44th president of the United States. The vaunted McCain comeback did not happen. Obama is widening his lead in the national polls. If you only cherry picked the state polls most favorable to McCain, Obama would STILL have over 300 electoral votes. Barack Obama has a better chance of winning Arizona than McCain has of winning Pennsylvania, Colorado, or Nevada. The only question most pollsters have will be where on the continuum Obama’s victory will lie, from a 3%, 286-252 electoral college victory to a 12%, 400-138 blowout.

Like so many other people out there, this election feels deeply personal to me, so much so that I sometimes tear up a little thinking about an Obama victory, and have even sung “We Will Overcome” in the car. I am not alone. I have spoken to many others who share my obsession. CNN even had a news segment on EOS, Election Obsession Syndrome.

The question is why? Certainly, part of the answer is Senator Obama himself, and his historic candidacy. He is the singularly most impressive political talent I have ever seen. Obama combines a keen intellect, a reassuring temperament, a soaring oratory, and a fundamental decency. He is able to balance icy resolve and pragmatic determination with idealism and optimism, an incredibly lethal combination. He has allowed the Clinton and Republican machines to defeat themselves while incurring barely a scratch (his approval ratings actually IMPROVED during the Ayers/terrorist/socialist silly season). He does it was with a preternatural calm and a disarming smile.

He is also the man of the moment. What an Obama victory tells the world about America, and tells America about itself, is urgently important to our collective identity. An Obama victory tells the world that America does not equal Bush and Cheney, and that America values cooperation and communication. We will listen. An Obama victory tells Americans that we have turned the page of the divisiveness of the last 40 years, and that America is embracing the diversity that is changing the American electorate.

An Obama victory will signal a new American moment. I think this moment, even more than Obama himself, has fueled my emotional connection to this election. Because this new American moment is mine. Ours. This moment is a testament to our wonderful diversity, which, like Obama’s face and family, is of colors of every hue.

It is also a moment of the liberal fusion of reason and emotion. Since Kennedy, Democratic candidates have spectacularly failed to emotionally connect with Americans, with the notable exception of Clinton, whose emotional connection was personal and not liberal. Reagan and Bush were the feel good connectors. Obama has changed the landscape, and has found a language, OUR LANGUAGE, to describe a progressive vision of America that resonates on both an emotional and intellectual level.

Finally, in this moment, we can put an end to the liberal/conservative trench warfare that has defined our country since Vietnam. Obama is progressive, more progressive in fact, than any candidate in our lifetime. But he is not partisan. He is more of a democrat than a Democrat. He is willing to reach across the metaphorical aisle and embrace voters who Democrats have long ago stopped trying to reach. That’s why he has a chance to win the kind of massive electoral victory undreamed of by Democrats in over 40 years. Since 1980, Democrats have been afraid of themselves and their beliefs. They have allowed liberal to become a dirty word. Gore, Kerry, and Clinton all had the stench of political fear, afraid if they were to reveal their true selves, they would lose their election. None of them ever articulated a full throated support of progressive taxation, the need universal health care, or our collective responsibilities for fear these messages would not resonate. They were wrong. Obama does not have the stench of fear. He has the stench of hope and optimism, and has lifted these important but long forgotten values onto American consciousness. Obama is also not afraid to embrace “conservative” ideas such as individual responsibility. Of course, individual responsibility is also a progressive value, but no progressive has talked about it for 40 years, because in the war for America’s soul during the Vietnam era, personal responsibility fell on the side of Nixon’s silent majority, and has stayed there ever since.

I also think in this moment, we are seeing the extinction burst of the hysterical right. An extinction burst is a behavioral term that describes a spike in a behavior right before it extinguishes. I think this is what we are seeing at the McCain/Palin rallies, and the angry delusional rhetoric of the Rush Limbaughs and Shean hannitys of the world. They sense their moment is over. They are angry and hurting, and are taking their last shots before they recede into acceptance. Of course, there is a dangerous strain out there of those who will not accept, and they need to be watched closely. Some will not accept that their moment has passed by. But is has. The moment is ours. If we use this moment to lord it over the Hannitys and Limbaughs, we risk creating the same rift in the electorate that happened to our parents’ generation 40 years ago. May we use this moment to bring out our better angels. May we use our moment to heal and to help. Obama has. So may we.

Dan Greco